1. | Dante Vanzeir (BEL - New York) | 5 |
2. | Marco Delgado (USA - LA Galaxy) | 4 |
3. | Luis Suarez (URU - Miami) | 3 |
4. | Fabian Herbers (GER - Chicago) | 2 |
| Josef Martinez (VEN - Montreal) | 2 |
| Aaron Herrera (GUA - DC United) | 2 |
| Denis Bouanga (GAB - Los Angeles FC) | 2 |
| Alexander Ring (FIN - Austin) | 2 |
| Kai Wagner (GER - Philadelphia) | 2 |
| Julian Aude (ARG - LA Galaxy) | 2 |
| Sang-Bin Jung (KOR - Minnesota) | 2 |
| Adalberto Carrasquilla (PAN - Houston) | 2 |
| Cristian Espinoza (ARG - San Jose) | 2 |
| Ricard Puig (ESP - LA Galaxy) | 2 |
| Daniel Salloi (HUN - Kansas City) | 2 |
| Brooks Lennon (USA - Atlanta) | 2 |
| Santiago Moreno (COL - Portland) | 2 |
| Tani Oluwaseyi (NGA - Minnesota) | 2 |
| Diego Rossi (URU - Columbus) | 2 |
| Yaw Yeboah (GHA - Columbus) | 2 |
| Brian White (USA - Vancouver) | 2 |
| Jack Skahan (USA - San Jose) | 2 |
| Carlos Gomez (COL - Salt Lake) | 2 |
| Juan Mosquera (COL - Portland) | 2 |
| Fidel Barajas (USA - Salt Lake) | 2 |
| Julian Gressel (USA - Miami) | 2 |
| Alonso Coello (ESP - Toronto) | 2 |
| Luciano Acosta (ARG - Cincinnati) | 2 |
29. | Georgios Giakoumakis (GRE - Atlanta) | 1 |
| Jared Stroud (USA - DC United) | 1 |
| Carlos Ferreira (PAR - Houston) | 1 |
| Samuel Adeniran (USA - St. Louis) | 1 |
| Jere Uronen (FIN - Charlotte) | 1 |
| Shaq Moore (USA - Nashville) | 1 |
| Taylor Washington (USA - Nashville) | 1 |
| Christian Benteke (BEL - DC United) | 1 |
| Indiana Vassilev (USA - St. Louis) | 1 |
| Ryan Raposo (CAN - Vancouver) | 1 |
| Gabriel Pec (BRA - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| Carles Gil (ESP - New England) | 1 |
| Gaston Brugman (URU - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| Aaron Long (USA - Los Angeles FC) | 1 |
| Dagur Dan Thorhallsson (ISL - Orlando) | 1 |
| Corey Baird (USA - Cincinnati) | 1 |
| Djibril Diani (FRA - Charlotte) | 1 |
| Joao Pedro (BRA - Charlotte) | 1 |
| Carlos Teran (COL - Chicago) | 1 |
| Jeremy Rafanello (USA - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| Sergi Palencia (ESP - Los Angeles FC) | 1 |
| Matthew Longstaff (ENG - Toronto) | 1 |
| Rafael Czichos (GER - Chicago) | 1 |
| Chris Brady (USA - Chicago) | 1 |
| Sergio Busquets (ESP - Miami) | 1 |
| Mathieu Choiniere (CAN - Montreal) | 1 |
| Julian Fernandez (ARG - New York City) | 1 |
| Lawson Sunderland (USA - Miami) | 1 |
| Ariel Lassiter (CRC - Montreal) | 1 |
| Tristan Blackmon (USA - Vancouver) | 1 |
| Ryan Gauld (SCO - Vancouver) | 1 |
| Federico Bernardeschi (ITA - Toronto) | 1 |
| David Morales (VEN - Los Angeles FC) | 1 |
| Ruan (BRA - Montreal) | 1 |
| Fabrice Picault (HAI - Vancouver) | 1 |
| Matias Coccaro (URU - Montreal) | 1 |
| Pedro Vite (ECU - Vancouver) | 1 |
| Jesus Ferreira (USA - Dallas) | 1 |
| Brecht Dejaeghere (BEL - Charlotte) | 1 |
| Preston Judd (USA - San Jose) | 1 |
| Bruno Wilson (POR - San Jose) | 1 |
| Cody Baker (USA - Seattle) | 1 |
| Mikael Uhre (DEN - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| Bernard Kamungo (TAN - Dallas) | 1 |
| Esmir Bajraktarevic (USA - New England) | 1 |
| Jacob Davis (USA - Kansas City) | 1 |
| Brian Gutierrez (USA - Chicago) | 1 |
| Keegan Rosenberry (USA - Colorado) | 1 |
| Tomas Totland (NOR - St. Louis) | 1 |
| Zan Kolmanic (SLO - Austin) | 1 |
| Eduard Loewen (GER - St. Louis) | 1 |
| Matt Crooks (ENG - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| Omar Campos (MEX - Los Angeles FC) | 1 |
| Iuri Tavares (CPV - Charlotte) | 1 |
| Matt Polster (USA - New England) | 1 |
| Pedro Santos (POR - DC United) | 1 |
| Jose Andres Martinez (VEN - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| Quinn Sullivan (USA - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| Mateusz Klich (POL - DC United) | 1 |
| Owen Wolff (USA - Austin) | 1 |
| Sam Junqua (USA - Dallas) | 1 |
| Ibrahim Aliyu (NGA - Houston) | 1 |
| Connor Ronan (IRL - Colorado) | 1 |
| Eryk Williamson (USA - Portland) | 1 |
| Cristhian Paredes (PAR - Portland) | 1 |
| Jordi Alba (ESP - Miami) | 1 |
| Joseph Rosales (HND - Minnesota) | 1 |
| Diego Luna (USA - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| Cristian Arango (COL - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| Orrin McKinze Gaines (USA - Nashville) | 1 |
| Federico Redondo (ARG - Miami) | 1 |
| Celio Pompeu (BRA - St. Louis) | 1 |
| Emil Forsberg (SWE - New York) | 1 |
| Anthony Markanich (USA - St. Louis) | 1 |
| Eric Miller (USA - Portland) | 1 |
| Dejan Joveljic (SRB - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| Joseph Paintsil (GHA - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| Antony (BRA - Portland) | 1 |
| Thiago Martins (BRA - New York City) | 1 |
| Lionel Messi (ARG - Miami) | 1 |
| Thiago Almada (ARG - Atlanta) | 1 |
| Maren Haile-Selassie (SWI - Chicago) | 1 |
| Malte Amundsen (DEN - Columbus) | 1 |
| Martin Ojeda (ARG - Orlando) | 1 |
| Leonardo Campana (ECU - Miami) | 1 |
| Robin Lod (FIN - Minnesota) | 1 |
| Rafael Santos (BRA - Orlando) | 1 |
| Miguel Tapias (MEX - Minnesota) | 1 |
| Johnny Russell (SCO - Kansas City) | 1 |
| Memo Rodriguez (USA - Kansas City) | 1 |
| Nathan Harriel (USA - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| Hector Jimenez (USA - Austin) | 1 |
| Sean Zawadzki (USA - Columbus) | 1 |
| Juan Hernandez (COL - Columbus) | 1 |
| Djordje Mihailovic (USA - Colorado) | 1 |
| Diego Gomez (PAR - Miami) | 1 |
| Deandre Kerr (CAN - Toronto) | 1 |