| 1. | Landon Donovan (VS - LA Galaxy) | 16 |
| 2. | Graham Zusi (VS - Kansas City) | 12 |
| | Thierry Henry (FRA - New York) | 12 |
| | Brad Davis (VS - Houston) | 12 |
| 5. | Mauro Rosales (ARG - Seattle) | 11 |
| 6. | Dwayne De Rosario (CAN - DC United) | 9 |
| | Marvin Chavez (HND - San Jose) | 9 |
| 8. | Felipe (BRA - Montreal) | 8 |
| | Robbie Keane (IER - LA Galaxy) | 8 |
| | Patrick Nyarko (GHA - Chicago) | 8 |
| 11. | Kei Ansu Kamara (SLE - Kansas City) | 7 |
| | Javier Damian Morales (ARG - Salt Lake) | 7 |
| | Camilo (BRA - Vancouver) | 7 |
| | Branko Boskovic (MNE - DC United) | 7 |
| | Patrice Bernier (CAN - Montreal) | 7 |
| | David Ferreira (COL - Dallas) | 7 |
| 17. | Fredy Montero (COL - Seattle) | 6 |
| | Federico Higuain (ARG - Columbus) | 6 |
| | Ramiro Corrales (VS - San Jose) | 6 |
| | Brian Mullan (VS - Colorado) | 6 |
| | Fabian Espindola (ARG - Salt Lake) | 6 |
| 22. | Martin Rivero (ARG - Colorado) | 5 |
| | Will Bruin (VS - Houston) | 5 |
| | Sean Franklin (VS - LA Galaxy) | 5 |
| | Alan Gordon (VS - San Jose) | 5 |
| | Chris Wondolowski (VS - San Jose) | 5 |
| | David Beckham (ENG - LA Galaxy) | 5 |
| | Shea Salinas (VS - San Jose) | 5 |
| | Sebastian Grazzini (ARG - Chicago) | 5 |
| | Eric Hassli (FRA - Toronto) | 5 |
| | Chris Tierney (VS - New England) | 5 |
| | Marco Pappa (GUA - Chicago) | 5 |
| 33. | Boniek Garcia (HND - Houston) | 4 |
| | Pavel Pardo (MEX - Chicago) | 4 |
| | Brian Ching (VS - Houston) | 4 |
| | Franck Songo'o (KMR - Portland) | 4 |
| | Steven Beitashour (IRN - San Jose) | 4 |
| | Yun-Pyo Lee (ZKO - Vancouver) | 4 |
| | Andy Najar (HND - DC United) | 4 |
| | Salvatore Zizzo (VS - Portland) | 4 |
| | Jairo Arrieta (CRC - Columbus) | 4 |
| | Sam Cronin (VS - San Jose) | 4 |
| | Chris Pontius (VS - DC United) | 4 |
| | Joel Lindpere (EST - New York) | 4 |
| | Sherjill MacDonald (NED - Chicago) | 4 |
| | Jack Jewsbury (VS - Portland) | 4 |
| | Adam Moffat (SCH - Houston) | 4 |
| | Kelyn Rowe (VS - New England) | 4 |
| | Luis Silva (VS - Toronto) | 4 |
| | Juninho (BRA - LA Galaxy) | 4 |
| | Jackson (BRA - Dallas) | 4 |
| | Hunter Freeman (VS - Colorado) | 4 |
| | Christian Tiffert (DUI - Seattle) | 4 |
| | Michael Farfan (VS - Philadelphia) | 4 |
| | Jaime Castrillon (COL - Colorado) | 4 |
| | Eric Alexander (VS - Portland) | 4 |
| 57. | Ashtone Morgan (CAN - Toronto) | 3 |
| | Dominic Oduro (GHA - Chicago) | 3 |
| | Eric Avila (VS - Toronto) | 3 |
| | Lionard Pajoy (COL - DC United) | 3 |
| | Maicon Santos (BRA - DC United) | 3 |
| | Chad Barrett (VS - LA Galaxy) | 3 |
| | Jan Gunnar Solli (NOR - New York) | 3 |
| | Alvaro Saborio (CRC - Salt Lake) | 3 |
| | Nick DeLeon (VS - DC United) | 3 |
| | Danny Cruz (VS - DC United) | 3 |
| | Chance Myers (VS - Kansas City) | 3 |
| | Julian de Guzman (CAN - Dallas) | 3 |
| | Blas Perez (PAN - Dallas) | 3 |
| | Gershon Koffie (GHA - Vancouver) | 3 |
| | Rafael Marquez (MEX - New York) | 3 |
| | Brandon Barklage (VS - New York) | 3 |
| | Kyle Beckerman (VS - Salt Lake) | 3 |
| | Davy Arnaud (VS - Montreal) | 3 |
| | Brandon McDonald (GUM - DC United) | 3 |
| | Brad Evans (VS - Seattle) | 3 |
| | Calen Carr (VS - Houston) | 3 |
| | Mike Magee (VS - LA Galaxy) | 3 |
| | Fabian Castillo (COL - Dallas) | 3 |
| | Josh Williams (VS - Columbus) | 3 |
| | Ryan Smith (ENG - Chivas USA) | 3 |
| | Rafael Baca (MEX - San Jose) | 3 |
| | Justin Mapp (VS - Montreal) | 3 |
| | Davide Chiumiento (ZWI - Vancouver) | 3 |
| | Chris Rolfe (VS - Chicago) | 3 |
| | Marc Burch (VS - Seattle) | 3 |
| | Miller Bolanos (ECU - Chivas USA) | 3 |
| | Saer Sene (FRA - New England) | 3 |
| | Alex Caskey (VS - Seattle) | 3 |
| | Khari Stephenson (JAM - San Jose) | 3 |
| 91. | Kalif Alhassan (GHA - Portland) | 2 |
| | Emilio Renteria (VEN - Columbus) | 2 |
| | Roger Espinoza (HND - Kansas City) | 2 |
| | Sebastien Le Toux (FRA - New York) | 2 |
| | Roy Miller (CRC - New York) | 2 |
| | Tim Cahill (AUS - New York) | 2 |
| | Nemanja Vukovic (MNE - Columbus) | 2 |
| | Andre Hainault (CAN - Houston) | 2 |
| | Justin Morrow (VS - San Jose) | 2 |
| | Brek Shea (VS - Dallas) | 2 |
| | James Riley (VS - Chivas USA) | 2 |
| | Shaun Francis (JAM - Columbus) | 2 |
| | Macoumba Kandji (SEN - Houston) | 2 |
| | Mehdi Ballouchy (MAR - New York) | 2 |
| | Benny Feilhaber (VS - New England) | 2 |
| | Steven Smith (SCH - Portland) | 2 |
| | Daniel Paladini (VS - Chicago) | 2 |
| | Tony Tchani (KMR - Columbus) | 2 |
| | Conor Casey (VS - Colorado) | 2 |
| | Victor Bernardez (HND - San Jose) | 2 |
| | Kosuke Kimura (JPN - Colorado) | 2 |
| | Christopher Korb (VS - DC United) | 2 |
| | Zach Scott (VS - Seattle) | 2 |
| | Hassoun Camara (FRA - Montreal) | 2 |
| | Eddie Johnson (VS - Seattle) | 2 |
| | Sheanon Williams (VS - Philadelphia) | 2 |
| | Danny Koevermans (NED - Toronto) | 2 |
| | Ned Grabavoy (VS - Salt Lake) | 2 |
| | Ben Zemanski (VS - Chivas USA) | 2 |
| | Camargo (BRA - Houston) | 2 |
| | Tony Cascio (VS - Colorado) | 2 |
| | Diego Fagundez (URU - New England) | 2 |
| | Shalrie Joseph (GRN - Chivas USA) | 2 |
| | Jack McInerney (VS - Philadelphia) | 2 |
| | Dilly Duka (VS - Columbus) | 2 |
| | Kenny Cooper (VS - New York) | 2 |
| | Dane Richards (JAM - Vancouver) | 2 |
| | Seth Sinovic (VS - Kansas City) | 2 |
| | Paulo Junior (BRA - Salt Lake) | 2 |
| | Reggie Lambe (BER - Toronto) | 2 |
| | Lamar Neagle (VS - Montreal) | 2 |
| | Miguel Aceval (CHL - Toronto) | 2 |
| | Sanna Nyassi (GAM - Montreal) | 2 |
| | Luis Gil (VS - Salt Lake) | 2 |
| | Dax McCarty (VS - New York) | 2 |
| | Nick Soolsma (NED - Toronto) | 2 |
| | Alvaro Fernandez (URU - Chicago) | 2 |
| | Juan Agudelo (VS - Chivas USA) | 2 |
| | Daniel Woolard (VS - DC United) | 2 |
| | Torsten Frings (DUI - Toronto) | 2 |
| | Connor Lade (VS - New York) | 2 |
| | Ryan Guy (GUM - New England) | 2 |
| | Will Johnson (CAN - Salt Lake) | 2 |
| | Tristan Bowen (VS - Chivas USA) | 2 |
| | Zach Loyd (VS - Dallas) | 2 |
| | Ryan Johnson (JAM - Toronto) | 2 |
| | Omar Cummings (JAM - Colorado) | 2 |
| 148. | Warren Creavalle (GUY - Houston) | 1 |
| | Amobi Okugo (VS - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Antoine Hoppenot (VS - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Marcelo Sarvas (BRA - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Peterson Joseph (HAI - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Barry Robson (SCH - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Charles Sapong (VS - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Adam Johansson (ZWE - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Sebastian Miranda (CHL - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Michael Gspurning (AUT - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Jalil Anibaba (VS - Chicago) | 1 |
| | Robbie Russell (VS - DC United) | 1 |
| | Sammy Ochoa (MEX - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Jose Villarreal (VS - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Steve Zakuani (VS - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Keon Daniel (TRI - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Laurent Courtois (FRA - Chivas USA) | 1 |
| | Matt Besler (VS - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Kenny Miller (SCH - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Jeff Parke (VS - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Chris Wingert (VS - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| | Matt Watson (ENG - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Jay Demerit (VS - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Darren O'Dea (IER - Toronto) | 1 |
| | Milovan Mirosevic (CHL - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Doneil Henry (CAN - Toronto) | 1 |
| | Bobby Boswell (VS - Houston) | 1 |
| | Matteo Ferrari (ITA - Montreal) | 1 |
| | Teal Bunbury (VS - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Drew Moor (VS - Colorado) | 1 |
| | Bryan Gaul (VS - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Andy Gruenebaum (VS - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Michael Stephens (VS - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Richard Eckersley (ENG - Toronto) | 1 |
| | Gabriel Farfan (VS - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Freddy Adu (VS - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Luis Eduardo Zapata (COL - Colorado) | 1 |
| | Kirk Urso (VS - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Stephen McCarthy (VS - New England) | 1 |
| | Osvaldo Alonso (CUB - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Simon Dawkins (JAM - San Jose) | 1 |
| | Matt Stinson (CAN - Toronto) | 1 |
| | Aaron Schoenfeld (VS - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Jonny Steele (NIR - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| | Rodney Wallace (CRC - Portland) | 1 |
| | Steven Lenhart (VS - San Jose) | 1 |
| | Casey Townsend (VS - Chivas USA) | 1 |
| | Cordell Cato (TRI - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Perry Kitchen (VS - DC United) | 1 |
| | Bobby Convey (VS - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Chris Schuler (VS - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| | Tony Beltran (VS - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| | Tressor Moreno (COL - San Jose) | 1 |
| | Todd Dunivant (VS - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Jordan Harvey (VS - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Rauwshan McKenzie (VS - Chivas USA) | 1 |
| | Jason Hernandez (VS - San Jose) | 1 |
| | Lewis Neal (ENG - DC United) | 1 |
| | Marcelo Saragosa (BRA - DC United) | 1 |
| | Roger Torres (COL - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Kevin Alston (VS - New England) | 1 |
| | Edson Buddle (VS - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Wilman Conde (COL - New York) | 1 |
| | Brian Ownby (VS - Houston) | 1 |
| | Jhon Hurtado (COL - Seattle) | 1 |
| | Fernando Cardenas (COL - New England) | 1 |
| | Michael Harrington (VS - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Blake Brettschneider (VS - New England) | 1 |
| | Brian Carroll (VS - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Hector Jimenez (VS - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
| | Florian Lechner (DUI - New England) | 1 |
| | Christopher Birchall (TRI - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Justin Meram (IRK - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Geoff Cameron (VS - Houston) | 1 |
| | Aurelien Collin (FRA - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Jorge Villafana (VS - Chivas USA) | 1 |
| | Alain Rochat (ZWI - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Jacob Peterson (VS - Kansas City) | 1 |
| | Andrew Jacobson (VS - Dallas) | 1 |
| | Eddie Gaven (VS - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Jermaine Taylor (JAM - Houston) | 1 |
| | Jonathan Top (VS - Dallas) | 1 |
| | Terukazu Tanaka (JPN - Salt Lake) | 1 |
| | Kris Boyd (SCH - Portland) | 1 |
| | Omar Salgado (VS - Vancouver) | 1 |
| | Sam Garza (VS - San Jose) | 1 |
| | Nelson Rivas (COL - Montreal) | 1 |
| | Eric Gehrig (VS - Columbus) | 1 |
| | Lee Nguyen (VS - New England) | 1 |
| | Justin Braun (VS - Montreal) | 1 |
| | Federico Puppo (URU - Chicago) | 1 |
| | Danny Mwanga (CGO - Philadelphia) | 1 |
| | Corey Ashe (VS - Houston) | 1 |
| | Christian Wilhelmsson (ZWE - LA Galaxy) | 1 |
